| 2024-2025 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
|---|---|---|---|
| ? | Shirley Estate Mothmen | John Suydam | |
| ? | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea | |
| ? | Neighborhood Roadies | Nick Muse | |
| ? | ? | ? | 2023-2024 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Biltmore Drivers | Colin Tully | Frank Semisa JJ Vernillo Ian Tully Matt King John Kossin Ken Silver |
| 2 | Neighborhood Roadies | Nick Muse | Evan Nick Geraci Kevin McCarthy Jesus Arancibia Joe Labo Matt Warner |
| 3 | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea | Nick Delmonte John Maca James McDermott Josh Paini Ray Sullivan Johnny Vega |
| 4 | Shirley Estate Mothmen | John Suydam | Justin O'Shea Wesley Sullivan Renzo Labo John Motovidlak +Dan Escobar |
2022-2023 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Shirley Estate Mothmen | John Suydam | Justin O'Shea Renzo Labo Nick Delmonte Josh Paini Tyler McCarthy John Kossin |
| 2 | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea | JJ Vernillo John Maca Jesus Arancibia Joe Labo Turkey John Motividlak |
| 3 | Neighborhood Roadies | Nick Muse | Frank Semisa Wesley Sullivan Nick Geraci Kevin McCarthy Ray Sullivan |
| 4 | Biltmore Drivers | Colin Tully | James McDermott Matt King Ken Silver Liam Matt Warner +Kyle Fichner |
2021-2022 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea | Frank Semisa JJ Vernillo Nick Geraci Jesus Arancibia Kevin McCarthy |
| 2 | Biltmore Drivers | Colin Tully | Ian Tully James McDermott Joe Labo Ray Sullivan John Motividlak |
| 3 | Shirley Estate Mothmen | John Suydam | Renzo Labo John Maca Matt King Josh Paini Matt Warner |
| 4 | Neighborhood Roadies | Nick Muse Dan Escobar |
Justin O'Shea Nick Delmonte Ken Silver Johnny Vega |
2020-2021 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Biltmore Drivers | Colin Tully Ian Tully |
Frank Labo Delmonte |
| 2 | Shirley Estate Mothmen | John Suydam Josh Paini |
John Maca Jesus Arancibia Pac |
| 3 | Neighborhood Roadies | Nick Muse Dan Escobar |
JJ Vernillo Nick Geraci Mike Ciaramella Matt Warner |
| 4 | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea Ken Silver |
Justin O'Shea Ray Sullivan Johnny Vega John Motividlak |
2019-2020 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Shirley Estate Mothmanian Devils | John Suydam | Justin O'Shea Frank Semisa Ken Silver Josh Paini |
| 2 | Neighborhood Roadies | Nick Muse Dan Escobar |
Nick Geraci John Maca Kevin McCarthy +JJ Vernillo |
| 3 | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea | Joe Labo Renzo Labo Ray Sullivan John Motividlak Marc Olivero |
| 4 | Smith Point Captains | Johnny Vega | Colin Tully Nick Delmonte Mike Ciaramella Tyler McCarthy |
2018-2019 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Poospatuck Smokes | Dan O'Shea | Renzo Labo Ray Sullivan Nick Muse John Maca +Wesley Sullivan |
| 2 | Smith Point Johnnies | Johnny Vega | Justin O'Shea Nick Delmonte Mike Ciaramella Josh Paini Ryan Hennessy |
| 3 | Team Osprey Park | Nick Geraci | Colin Tully Joe Labo John Motividlak Nino Tyler McCarthy |
| 4 | Team Moth | John Suydam | Frank Semisa Wesley Sullivan Steve Nezario Josh Paini Ryan Hennessy |
2017-2018 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Team Frank | Frank Semisa | John Maca Wesley Sullivan Joe Labo Renzo Labo Nick Geraci |
| 2 | Team Johnny | Johnny Vega | Justin O'Shea Mike Ciaramella Ken Silver Dan Escobar Ryan Hennessy |
| 3 | Team Dan | Dan O'Shea | Marc Olivero Ian Tully Nick Delmonte Ray Sullivan John Motividlak Elliot Kim |
| 4 | Team Holmes | John Suydam | Colin Tully Steve Nezario Tyler McCarthy Nick Muse Nino |
2016-2017 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Team Frank | Frank Semisa | USC Steve Justin O'Shea Ken Silver Renzo Labo |
| 2 | Team Holmes | Holmes | Colin Tully John Motividlak Nino Joe Labo Ryan Hennessy |
| 3 | Team Dan | Dan O'Shea | Ian Tully Nick Delmonte Tyler McCarthy Ray Sullivan Marc Olivero |
| 4 | Team |
Steve Nezario John Maca Dan Escobar Nick Geraci |
2015-2016 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Team Frank | Frank Semisa | Justin O'Shea Ian Tully Colin Tully Nino Johnny Vega John Maca Joe Labo |
| 2 | Team Holmes | John Suydam | USC Steve Nick Geraci John Motividlak Nick Muse Ray Sullivan Dan Escobar |
2014-2015 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Team Frank | Frank Semisa | Ian Tully Justin O'Shea Joe Labo Nick Geraci John Suydam |
| 2 | Team Dan | Dan O'Shea | Colin Tully Renzo Labo John Motividlak Nino Marc Olivero Nick Muse John Semisa |
2013-2014 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Team Dan | Dan O'Shea | Dan Escobar Justin O'Shea Renzo Labo Joe Labo Nino John Suydam Colin Tully |
| 2 | Team Frank | Frank Semisa | Ian Tully Nick Geraci Johnny Vega Ken Silver Nick Muse Mike Ciaramella Elias |
2012-2013 | Place | Team | Coach | Roster |
| 1 | Team Frank | Frank Semisa | Justin O'Shea Dan Escobar Marc Olivero Mike Ciaramella Ray Sullivan Some Mastoid |
| 2 | Team Dan | Dan O'Shea | John Suydam Joe Labo Renzo Labo Nino Ian Tully Colin Tully |
Charity Football League